According to this New York Times article, Speaker Nancy Pelosi has proclaimed that, “The glory days are coming to an end for health insurers.” Glory days? Are you kidding me?
Health insurers have struggled mightily over the past years, to the point that their numbers are dwindling. The cost of health care has made it anything but “glory days.”
My biggest issue coming out of this article is focused on what I believe Ms. Pelosi is crowing about - making it mandatory for people to be insured, regardless of their health history and current illnesses for no additional cost. This is called “adverse selection,” or in layman’s terms “stupid.”
In theory it sounds great doesn’t it? Everyone gets the same insurance for the same cost. Oh happy days! But wait a minute, if a health insurer has to pay out more for one person, but not be able to bring in more, won’t this cause a deficit? The answer is YES.
Consider this analogy…
You and I both have auto insurance. We drive the same car, live in the same area, and are the same age. You are a prudent driver with no accidents or tickets. On the other hand, I’ve managed to get involved in two accidents in the last three years and have three speeding tickets. I also let my 17-year daughter old drive it around town on occasion and you know she takes after me with the lead foot. Who is more likely to cause higher costs to the insurer? That’s right…me. However, I get a great deal on insurance because the government mandates we both pay the same.
After a couple of years of doing this, the insurer is forced to raise rates on everyone to keep up with costs. The claims by drivers like me are driving them into bankruptcy (sound familiar) and the only way to stay afloat is to increase rates. But, since we all have to be the same, your rates go up too, even though you’ve done nothing wrong. Happy?
Here’s the bottom line - Insurers of any kind - property, auto, health, liability, must be able to rate premiums according to exposure. When they don’t, everyone must suffer. This will happen in this new health care package and to make matters worse, YOU are one of the insurers. The government (through your tax dollars) is an insurer and will have the same issues that private companies do.
Health insurance can’t be equitable for all. Just like auto insurance rates are higher for drivers who are higher risk, so must premiums for higher in health insurance to compensate for exposure.
So Ms. Pelosi, you are correct. Happy days are gone for health insurers. Unfortunately, they are probably gone for the American taxpayer, too.
Read the NY Times article
Be safe and be well.
